"...on the villainous side is Caitlin Cisler as the sensational Armida. Her remarkable soprano accompanied by her movements fit the dastardly persona to a tee. Cisler's electricity radiated through the space while she played each moment to its fullest."
- Broadway World
“But it was Cisler as Marie who floated and flitted and sparkled and sang, easily combining winsome appeal with coloratura chops.”
- Madison Magazine
"Cisler provided a perfect foil as the page Oscar, one of Verdi's few high-coloratura soprano roles. Her beautifully piping voice was exceeded only by her delightfully spirited acting -- a performance to be cherished."
- The Daily Page
"...Cisler has a strong and thrilling voice; her performance
transcends the text.”
- The Wisconsin State Journal